Former Miss Gay USofA Newcomers

Eva De Leon - Miss Gay USofA Newcomer 2018

Domita Sanchez - Miss Gay USofA Newcomer 2017

Vanity St. James - Miss Gay USofA Newcomer 2016

Mari Jane - Miss Gay USofA Newcomer 2015

Kira Daniels - Miss Gay USofA Newcomer 2014

Tonica E. Cavalli - Miss Gay USofA Newcomer 2013

Ka'aliyah McKim Diamond - Miss Gay USofA Newcomer 2012

Arianna Evans - Miss Gay USofA Newcomer 2011

Phalon M. Steele - Miss Gay USofA Newcomer 2010